Project 2 : Grading Criteria
Visual Sensitivity, Craftsmanship & Control
Excellent
41-50 pts
Highest degree of attention to detail and strongest demonstration of consideration of the arrangement of typographic elements. No problems found in work submitted.
Above Average
31-40 pts
High degree of attention to detail and strong demonstration of consideration of the arrangement of typographic elements. A few minor problems found.
Average
21-30 pts
Moderate degree of attention to detail and average demonstration of consideration of the arrangement of typographic elements. Multiple minor problems found or a major problem was found.
Below Average
11-20 pts
Low degree of attention to detail and weak demonstration of consideration of the arrangement of typographic elements. Multiple major problems found.
Unacceptable
0-10 pts
Lowest degree of attention to detail and little demonstration of consideration of the arrangement of typographic elements. Student demonstrates a significant misunderstanding of qualities of craftsmanship necessary to complete assignment.
Project Parameters
Excellent
21-25 pts
All instructions followed correctly. No problems found in work submitted.
Above Average
16-20 pts
Almost all of instructions followed correctly. A few minor problems found.
Average
11-15 pts
Most of the instructions followed correctly. Multiple minor problems found or a major problem was found.
Below Average
11-20 pts
Some of the instructions correctly followed. Multiple Major Problems found.
Below Average
6-10 pts
Student did not follow instructions. Student demonstrates a significant misunderstanding of how to correctly complete this assignment.
Participation in Final Critique
Excellent
21-25 pts
Student demonstrates leadership in eliciting other students to participate in group critique during majority of class period. Student demonstrates a strong interest and excitement by freely participating in critique during entire class period.
Above Average
16-20 pts
Student demonstrates limited leadership skills during a portion of the class period. Student demonstrates helpfulness toward other students while participating in group critique during entire class period. Student demonstrates interest and excitement by freely participating in critique during entire class period.
Average
11-15 pts
Student demonstrates helpfulness toward other students while participating in group critique during most of the class period. Student demonstrates interest and excitement by freely participating in critique during most of the class period.
Below Average
6-10 pts
Student only participated in group critique when called upon to do so by instructor or other students. Student demonstrates weak interest and little excitement during critique.
Unacceptable
0-5 pts
Student did not actively participate in group critique. Student demonstrated behavior that was passive or distant during most or all of the class period.